The ATO should apply lessons it has learnt about dealing with victim-survivors of financial abuse, coercive control and family and domestic violence to the self-managed super fund sector where these matters are also relevant, the SMSF Association has stated.
The professional body made the suggestion in a submission to the Tax Ombudsman’s review of the ATO’s administration of director penalty notices (DPN), which includes consideration of whether the regulator appropriately and consistently identifies and responds to vulnerability, coerced directorship and financial abuse.
The association noted while its submission did not address the operation of the DPN regime, any practical applications relating to victim-survivors should be applied across the ATO.
“This is directly relevant to the SMSF sector. Where an SMSF has a corporate trustee, members are required to also be directors of the trustee company,” the submission noted.
“A victim-survivor may be fraudulently or coercively appointed as a director or may initially consent to the appointment before the corporate trustee structure or the SMSF is subsequently used by a perpetrator as a mechanism of control.
“This may expose the victim-survivor’s superannuation benefits to unauthorised access or misuse. It may also expose them to non-concessional tax rates, administrative penalties, SMSF compliance action or director disqualification arising from conduct over which they had little control.”
The association identified a number of transferable learnings that should apply to SMSF administration, including early identification and specialist escalation of issues.
“Indicators of coercion and financial abuse, trauma-informed questioning and referral pathways identified through the DPN review should also be embedded into the ATO’s SMSF compliance and regulatory processes,” the submission added.
“This should include cases involving suspected unauthorised access to SMSF benefits, misuse of fund assets, non-lodgement or inaccurate reporting, trustee disqualification and other compliance consequences potentially arising from a perpetrator’s conduct.”
Where information about a vulnerable individual is identified, within privacy safeguards, this should be visible to all relevant ATO business lines to prevent one part providing support while another takes compliance action.
Additionally, where victim-survivors are unable to produce direct evidence of a perpetrator’s conduct or their own lack of involvement, the ATO was called upon to adopt proportionate evidentiary approaches in cases involving alleged coercion or financial abuse, including using information from trusted third parties.
Lastly, the submission suggested where the ATO commissioner had discretion in regards to compliance consequences and penalties, any decisions should consider if the conduct or liability came about because of coercion or financial abuse, and the ability for an affected person to have prevented it.
